by Puffs » Sun Dec 08, 2019 6:12 am
Hi Hockers!
Surprised to hear that battery was a tight fit, as AGM's often are slightly smaller & lighter than their conventional lead-acid counterpart. Does the one you fitted have a higher capacity?
Yes, something like a flour sieve (with holes of typically 1x1 mm) is sometimes used in road racing, then aimed at preventing big particles to enter the engine. Then the conscious focus is on performance, rather than longevity of the engine. It is understood that, if you ride in a dusty environment with only such a sieve, you'll get more rapid wear on valve stems/guides/seals/seats, piston, bore, ...
For filtering the air properly, I do not recommend the air filter you describe:
- The last thing you want to happen is that your filter looses strands of stainless steel into the intake air stream. Filters are there to avoid that sort of thing to enter the engine. The glue on the duct tape is likely to dissolve due to the presence of some petrol, at least over time. At any rate, not a risk I'd like to take. I'd suggest to immobilise the edges by placing them in a rim of epoxy.
- What you describe is not an effective air filter (1x1 holes are too big), or it will actually give a higher pressure drop than a common paper filter (if the holes are much smaller than the flour sieve I looked at, but then the surface area is much smaller than that of a paper filter, which has many folds).
- A thin oil, or WD40, might indeed catch the occasional very fine particle, but the oil being thin means it has a very low viscosity and no significant gel strength, and is not very sticky at all. Under the prolonged flow caused by the engine, a particle that has somehow become stuck in the (very thin) oil layer, will move to the leeward side of the sieve, and then over time just un-stick & continue its journey into the engine - which is exactly what you wanted to prevent happening. Note that oils commonly used to oil foam filters (as used in MX) are actually very thick & sticky oils, with a high gel strength, dissolved in a special solvent that evaporates after application.
I know there are so-called 'high flow' filters from companies like K&N, made from cotton between a course mesh, and that they are oiled with an oil spray, but I sincerely have my doubts if they filter effectively. IMHO the only way to increase the flow (or reduce the ΔP over the filter), while retaining the same filter efficiency, is by increasing the surface area of the filter material. And the idea of particles being caught in a layer of sticky oil requires a tortuous path through the filter, as in a foam filter.
Also, note that an engine can run well with any sort of filter, as long as the jetting is adapted to the flow (or pressure drop) from that filter. Normally: different type of filter --> adapt jetting.
Last edited by
Puffs on Mon Jan 06, 2025 8:10 am, edited 2 times in total.