by Puffs » Wed Apr 04, 2018 11:18 am
Overheating coil: haven't a clue. As far as I can see, should have no link with whatever goes on in the cylinder/head/compression.
It could be caused by the breaker being closed too long.
I'm sorry, it's been more than 13years since I worked on the ignition of my MZ (haven't run that bike since I live here), and I don't remember what that cam profile is like. But the Jawa I mentioned has a cam profile with a long open time. From closed, an initial rise (and you get the spark the moment the points open), then it stays open for a long time (about 160°), then it opens a bit further, in order to close with a bang, thus allowing good contact. Then the coil starts to charge, for about 170°, and some 2.8mm before TDC the breaker opens again & you get a spark at the plug. But that's a 180° parallel twin, with a breaker + coil per cylinder, and I always figured that they kept the breaker open for so long, in order to have no more than 1 coil being charged at the time & draining the battery (before the engine runs).
But if you now tell me the ETZ has a similar long open time, I cannot understand how that engine can run backwards. It's not dieseling, is it? So you need a spark. You only get a spark when the breaker opens, not when it closes. So for it to run backwards, the breaker has to close some 20° after TDC, when running in the normal direction. Then it opens some 20° before TDC when running backwards, and the cam profile would be approximately symmetric over the TDC-point.
Machining such a cam (or lobe as you call it) is not easy. (And I would not take out the hump at the end; I think you need that to get good contact.) I was only thinking about it in the sense of having a longer open time (to prevent running backwards & also have a cooler coil & less current drain), but if the standard profile has a long open time already, the idea is a non-starter.
+++++++++++
Edit/add:
I just had a look on my ETZ251, which has the original ignition & electrics.
- I verified that you only get a spark when you break the connection, so when the breaker opens. You can check this quite easily: put a plug in the cap & lay the plug body on the earth. Pull the green wire off the connection with the breakers, you can then easily simulate the opening/closing of the breaker: green-to-earth = breaker closed (& coil charging); green-unconnected = breaker open. And you can see (when you switch on the ignition) when it sparks: making the connection gives no spark, breaking it gives a spark.
- With the standard cam, the breaker is indeed open for something like 200°, as you said. It closes when the piston is on the way back up, but still close to BDP. So that's when it sparks if the engine is running backwards: then the breaker opens a little before BDC, and closes 2.5-3.0 mm after TDC. So for the life of me, I can't understand how it can run backwards with that ignition, and what I said earlier about modifying the breaker cam is nonsense. The standard cam is fine (of course).
This cam profile is quite different from that found on 60's MX bikes. Those have no battery (so no coil heating issues), and the breaker is closed for much longer, with a profile more or less symmetrical around TDC.
Last edited by
Puffs on Mon Jan 06, 2025 6:52 am, edited 2 times in total.